What is wrong with bashing errors or bursting fantasy balloons ? Unless of course you subscribe to it . Re-read the post it wasn't bashing Thom , it was bashing those who conflate Thom and Watkins and add a bit of fantasy .
I was pointing out that that aligners who make claims for the siting of monuments being related to cols and peaks can easily proven to be wrong .
Go and visit and you will see how the astro events occur on featureless parts of the horizon , and the obvious features are avoided . You have been given the info , prove it wrong ?
The relationship between monuments and their respective landscapes can be as complex and as interesting as you wish to make it but it has nothing to do with astro events being related to peaks and cols ,you may "feel" what you like , but reality intrudes and it doesn't work .
would you like further examples from the area ?