The Celts BBC2

thesweetcheat wrote:
A very good response which (for me) added quite a bit of context to the programme. Needless to say I liked the references to women in prehistory ...

"And if they’re not migrating, I learn that Celts are fighting. And that they were all men; which is odd because in some regions, at some times, the archaeological record distinctly tells us that Early Iron Age society was really more to do with the power of women. Maybe the female rulers of the late Hallstatt period will be in the next episode. For now, I’m learning that the Celtic hordes were male, that the iron workers were male, and that the leaders were male. I always wonder when I encounter these utopian masculinist visions of my period, how these men reproduced ...."

Rachel Pope is Senior Lecturer in European Prehistory at the University of Liverpool - I wonder if she is expecting too much from a television programme which is not really aimed at students of archaeology, rather a wider audience with a more general interest.

Yes, I thought it was a very good piece.

My impression from reading it was that her criticism was not so much about the lack of depth, more about the (over) reliance on Roman "histories" over the last 25 years of archaeological evidence, which struck me too.

I didn't pick up on the dotting about from period to period, but once it's pointed out I'm not sure why the producers decided to do that. A bit like making a program about the Tudors and occasionally throwing in information about the English Civil War.