close

Recently I was informed that an old book I used for research whilst writing Monu-Mental About Prehistoric Antrim was available now as a print on demand book, so I ordered a copy.

It turned up yesterday and I was gobsmacked at how bad it is. What I think they've done is simply take the text version from Google books and print it. As we all know, the OCR in google books is pretty poor and there is very little proof reading (if any). Also, where there are images in the scan there is just gobbledegook in the text.

Every page you open the book at has many glaring errors! Several words merged; missing words; duplicated words; words that just don't exist ... you name it, it's got it!

There's a huge danger here that books like this will cause new and incorrect versions of quotes to be used, and that these versions shall become the norm over time.

My advice? Only buy a Print on Demand reprint if it states that it's a full facsimile of the original.

Are you going to try and get your money back? Or maybe it's more hassle than it's worth? Hate to see them get away with it.

Sounds rather annoying, to say the least. Cheers for the warning/advice though.

Name names Tom, whodunnit?

Do you know if it was approved by the author???? (Presumably it couldn't be done without their approval???)

love

Moth

That's pretty bloody shocking, actually!

I agree with the above sentiments: name and shame!

Just so we know who to avoid, like...

G x

Hi Tom,
Sorry to hear that you bought a cat in the sack (Dutch expression).
Have you tried to find the book on the Internet Archive:
http://www.archive.org/index.php ?
Cheers,
Jan

I bought a print on demand book about the History of Jet on Ebay, it was like a too dark photocopy for the most part, totally unlike the one in the library which had also been a print on demand but looked fine. Signed by the author was probably not real either.