New to all this

close

hi all
im kinda new to all this.
been visiting stones for about a year.
i have loads of questions but they are probably old news to everyone here.

ill start with one thats been bugging me for a while.

why does stone henge have the stones on top of the other stones when all the other stone circles are just standing stones?

this is probably a stupid question, but unless you ask you dont learn.

to bails you out present opinion is that the trilthons are in imitation of carpentry joints

If You want the absolute truth..

Then....

Nobody has a clue...

Tony

hmmmm .... "why" .... er ... good question. Dunno!

sleeptowin wrote:
why does stone henge have the stones on top of the other stones when all the other stone circles are just standing stones?
Why do major cities around the world seek to build the tallest buildings?

Maybe the added structure of Stonehenge was the ancient equivalent of building the Empire State building, a bit of engineering prowess.

Humans aren't so different, nor were they so different. They like to impress with their works.

I thought it was to turn a run of the mill bluestone threshing machine into a state of the art Salisbury wind driven grinding machine ;)

Or did someone else already come up with this idea?

Ayup & welcome! We all started somewhere!

There are loads of theories, but as others have said, nobody don't knows - especially why it's the only one. (There have been claims that a cuppla others had at least one 'lintel'-type arrangement but as far as I know, the evidence was pretty non-existent).

There are loads of theories of what Stonehenge was for, and many of those involve the lintels. They range from the very plausible (for example, to create a lightbox arrangement for the sun and/or moon at the solstices) to the (to most people) completely ridiculous (I'm not getting into those!!!) and every point inbetween (for example, that it had a roof).

Have a google of it! ;^)

love

Moth

Hi sleeptowin.
As you'll have gathered, no-one knows the answer but my theory is that it wasn't the only one but all the others were wood and rotted away.

If you look at the lintels you'll see they each have 2 different classic carpentry joints in 4 different positions, AND they're curved. Ideal for a small wooden structure with tight joints but a bit mad for huge and very hard stones. Also, a pointless design because unlike in wood there was no way the joints could be made tight fitting or have dowels inserted. It looks like a show-off piece rather than a well-designed one.

The cromlechs are roofed, don't forget - just differently. The stone doorways of Stonehenge echo some bits of Egyptian architecture of a similar age. This suggests that the architects were aware of what the Egyptians were doing and copied it (slightly).

thanks for all the replys, i thought i may have been asking something quite obvious. but it looks like everyone has different answers. so no one knows for sure.

i think i may be joining in here a bit more now. if thats ok with everyone else?

Hi sleeptowin.
Feel free to ask any seemingly silly or obvious questions mate, it may just give me a chance to answer something for a change. ; )