close
more_vert

Oh yeah, I am sure that many discoveries lie there to prove us all partly wrong one day. I know of the contrasts with Galloway in rock art, Bradley makes that quite clear in his comparative studies. I still trust the generalizations though and the way his studies follow 'tendencies'. If 90% follow a certain trend then there must be something there. Still, I am convinced that each area must have had, like with the building of megalithic graves in Britain, their own regionalisms. Yes, even in a country like Galicia there is always a tiny area that breaks the general rule. After all, they were human and competition and dissent has always been pretty common. Valcamonica is also a fascinating place isn't it but I cannot comment much about it except say that I love it.

I also love the way that Hoskin's magnificent work of passage grave orientations (you know the SE/E generalizations) were shattered when he came across the great passage graves of Pastora (near Seville), one with the longest corridor ever - nearly 50 metres - the other one 40 metres. After months of intensive study and finding that nearly all had winter solstice sunrise orientations, the biggest one was orientated west!

And of course we shouldn't forget that rock art was created over a period of 1000-2000 years and longer in some areas, and meanings and intentions faded to be replaced by new ones. Thus it is also possible that deviations from the norm could also date to 500 years later. And you know that rock art is extremely difficult to date.

I don't know the Hoskins connection to Pastora could you give me the title , it looks good .Similar shifts in attitudes may happen in RA studies too. There are lots of ingrained ways of thinking in the study of RA that are not necessarily backed up by the evidence . Personally I have big doubts about , pathways & intervisibility , complex motifs being on the higher ground , complexity itself being considered from the purely visual i.e. numbers of rings and uncommon motifs highlight certain sites when the vast majority of cases are quite simple and rarely get considered in the equation , the importance attached to drawings (which I almost prefer to pics ) which priveleges a certain viewpoint and doesn't consider the immediate texture , colour and gradations of the surface and wider landsape (difficult to do ) but the end result is concentrated on the motifs .

"I also love the way that Hoskin's magnificent work of passage grave orientations (you know the SE/E generalizations) were shattered when he came across the great passage graves of Pastora (near Seville), one with the longest corridor ever - nearly 50 metres - the other one 40 metres. After months of intensive study and finding that nearly all had winter solstice sunrise orientations, the biggest one was orientated west! "

Is this study just in Spain?