Rhiannon,
I understand what you're trying to say, but I do agree with SG, as everyone is entitled to an opinion of any site, whether that be good or bad.
The more fieldnotes given to a site means that a better view can be gleaned of it before a visit.
Negative views are just as useful as positive ones for a prospective visitor.
What better way of deciding wheter to travel hundreds of miles? If there's a load of negatives, then why bother? True, when you arrive you may not agree, but other's views may make you think twice, or encourage you.
If we all thought the same it would be quite a sterile site, or do I mean forum.
Life's rich pageant eh?
Regards and respect,
TE.