close
more_vert

>But imagine that landscape thousands of years later (let's say shortly after the extinction of our species): the trees are gone; the earth has been levelled; structures of metal and stone stand in dissarray. What you are imagining are formal structures imposed upon the earth by man. The fact that the structures are utilitarian does not mean that they teach you nothing about man. Interpretation of those relics would reveal facts about the way we lived, the technology we had at our disposal, and what we conceived as our goals in life.,

I hear what you're saying Nick, and I don't disagree with it, but how accurate is the 'interpretation of those relics' going to be? If people today build wonderful astronomical, sacred theories around stone circles (when in fact some of those circles may have actually just been corrals) then something has gone seriously wrong with the interpretation. We can marvel at the effort and ingenuity of the people who built ancient structures but if we then label the reasons for their efforts with the wrong interpretation we are doing them (and ourselves) a great disservice.

>>>If people today build wonderful astronomical, sacred theories around stone circles (when in fact some of those circles may have actually just been corrals) then something has gone seriously wrong with the interpretation. We can marvel at the effort and ingenuity of the people who built ancient structures but if we then label the reasons for their efforts with the wrong interpretation we are doing them (and ourselves) a great disservice.<<<

We often take into account the folkloric evidence as a hint of what may have gone on, future interpretation of our generation's relics will do the same in the absence of written records surviving.

If the circle builders wanted to corral livestock, why didn't they use 4 ft tall thin stones so they could easily weave withies or brush or thorn between them. I can't think of any circle that would lend itself to being easily used in this way and what about a gate? Why go to all that effort when there are easier ways? Are any circles called sheepfold or pinfold? Is there a link to the Stones List please as I don't want to go off topic here.

Rune

Who is we ? (when we interperate)
Are we serious about the circles being corrals ?
Who is able to find an answer , when an opinion is crushed ?
Does we crush the opposite opinion, is we the one with the biggest opinion ?
Does we know the answer ?
Is we superior to me, or is it just that we think we is ?
We,we,we,we, looking in, as some are, all they see is we, we, we.