Well what did you lot decide while I was incommunicado? There's no way I've got time to go trawling back, so can you bung us a draft by email Nigel?

love

Moth

PS I missed the whole 'HA Online' thread btw but will try to have a look at it this evening!!!

Moth, I'll post it here in case anyone wants to comment further, as nothing was actually decided.

Your draft was at http://www.themodernantiquarian.com/forum/?thread=14294&message=150193&offset=25

and there were these comments:

<What gives English Heritage the right to give so little information?>
I know what you mean Moth, but it sounds a little iffy. Are EH obliged to disseminate info? in which case:
<What gives English Heritage the right to withhold information?>
or even in the light of the safety notice removal
<What gives English Heritage the right to prevent information being disseminated?>
...................
I personally think the wording is too complex and technical.
They are better put into a standard letter for people to send to EH than on a petition.
Better to have a petition that requires a single outcome, than a complicated one that EH can say has been delivered on with a few glib answers. Try not to get too fussed about the way EH go about things. What is the goal here? To get information, or action?
"It has come to my attention that the ancient monument of Silbury Hill is in serious danger of collapse, this has been known about by English Heritage since it first suffered an internal collapse in XXXXX yet the structure is still in an unstable state.
It is urgent that English Heritage address this situation as soon as possible, as further collapses have been noted, indicating this fine ancient monument is in need of immediate remedial action.
It is my desire that English Heritage address this situation with the utmost urgency."
................
Brigantes knows what he's talking about. Keep it simple or get in a muddle with people signing up to thngs they don't understand- or not signing 'cos they only agree/understand bits of it.
................
I agree Brigantes' advice is very good sense. I'd only add that the demand should also be for openness as well as action. Otherwise, they could simply say yes, we WILL repair it ASAP and our demand for it to be done would be answered. If they're open about the plans the public has a chance to comment and be reassured.
...............
Yes, ES, you're right. We've got to be sure that any facts that are expressed can be proven. If we can't it's best to stick to more subjective stuff: "We feel that...", "It would seem that...", "It would appear that...", etc.
.............
Despite the mound suffering more collapses since, English Heritage*,* who are responsible for the World Heritage monument*,* have not yet authorised work to repair the damage or *to* prevent *further* damage *from occurring*.
We, the undersigned, demand that *its* statutorily appointed guardians, English Heritage, break their silence about the reasons for the delay and share with the public what is known and what is planned.