DOWSING

close

Dowsing on the TMA always raises a long and controversial thread. Its a bit like the Marmite ads - you either love it or hate it! I propose a suck it and see approach for the more skeptical or cynical amongst us, or for the just plain curious:

Run up to your wardrobe, grab a pair of wire coat hangers and an old bog roll. Snip the hook off the coat hangers and trim off one of the curved corners until you're left with an 'L' shape. One length should be about 10" and the other about 5". Take your bog roll and slit it, and open it flat. Cut into two equal pieces, roll each one into a tube about as thick as your little finger, pop the short arm of the wire into the tube, so it rolls freely - but doesnt fall out! Secure the tube with tape. Get yourself out into the garden/yard/field wherever and hold each rod in the hand, firmly but not tightly and allow the rods to settle roughly perpendicular to the ground, parralel to each other. Wander about - where the rods cross make a note and come at it from other directions to triangulate. Thats all there is to it! Its actually more trouble to make the damn things than it is to use 'em! If you find it works - LMK!

I think you'll find that most of the 'against camp' aren't against dowsing itself, just some of the ridiculous claims made by some of those practicing it :-)

I don't bother with tubes; I just hold them loosely in the hands. If you can't manage well enough then try Bic biros with the insides ripped out.

I think your explanation of the position of the rods was a little misleading, you said they should be held perpendicular to the ground and parallel to each other. It depends which part of the L-shape you are refering to. The part that's held in the hands needs to be perpendicular to the ground, but the part pointing out in front should be parallel to the ground. I mention that just in case some would-be dowser should think that his rods need to point vertically downwards.

James Randi is offering a $1,000,000 reward to anyone who can demonstrate a "paranormal" phenomenon under controlled double-blind conditions and apparently dowsing qualifies as paranormal by his definition. The rules are straightforward. You design your own test conditions and state what constitutes a successful outcome. If Randi is happy that the test is valid and that your measure of success is significantly better than random chance, the challenge is on. You get an initial trial and if that is successful then a full media-coverage demonstration is required.

A test that was suggested as being suitable for dowsing was to lay sealed plastic pipes down on the ground in a field. Some would contain water and some would be empty. Those laying the pipes would then leave the site and the dowser would attempt to identify which pipes contained water. The nice thing about this experiment is that possible pre-knowledge of the site is irrelevant and success can be measured as a probabilty and compared directly with random chance.

Having dowsed successfully myself, I thought, "I could do that", but quite a few dowsers have had a go, and yet so far the prize has not been claimed. Randi says that of all the people who try the challenge, dowsers are the most genuinely surprised when they fail.

Anyone up for it? Read more at:

http://www.randi.org/research/index.html

What about hands on healing? Impossible to prove but I know it sometimes works.

I like Ian Honeywood`s site:

http://www.sover.net/~ihoneywo/

Don`t know what to make of it (and he doesn`t seem to, either) but I do find it all......intriguing.

So has no-one taken up my challenge and ripped up the bog roll and raided the wardrobe yet ?

I have been dowsing for gold for 5 years. I have a group site for information exchange. No skeptics allowed...Art http://groups.aol.com/dowsersweare