tiompan

tiompan

All posts expand_more 101-150 of 1,734 posts

Gobekli Tepe .Response from excavators

tepetelegrams.wordpress.com/2017/04/21/archaeoastronomy-meteor-showers-mass-extinction-what-does-the-fox-say-and-what-the-crane-the-aurochs/

A useful response from the excavators ,mainly related to the problems connected with the nonsense about about the symbols and cherry picking .
It’s not to be expected that they might have noticed that the astronomy was also wrong i.e. the asterisms were actually below the horizon on their chosen solstice date . Possibly why the images highlighted them during the day when they were above the horizon but invisible .
No mention either of the suggested date of the observation being a thousand years earlier than the earliest date from the site .
Hopefully the Telegraph and New Scientist will give this the space it deserves .

Gobekli Tepe

Ancient stone carvings confirm how comet struck Earth in 10,950BC, sparking the rise of civilisations .

telegraph.co.uk/science/2017/04/21/ancient-stone-carvings-confirm-comet-struck-earth-10950bc-wiping/

Even the New Scientist fell for this nonsense .

The paper is here .
maajournal.com/Issues/2017/Vol17 ... 281%29.pdf
Well worth a read if you enjoy fantasies .

Ideal fodder for the saddos who have a problem with experts .
In this case the expertise of the authors ( chemical engineering ) is unrelated to the content .
Not dissimilar to geomorphologists writing “papers ” about archaeology .

The Uffington White Horse geoglyph as sun-horse .

DOI: doi.org/10.15184/aqy.2016.269

Josh Pollard has an interesting paper in the most recent “Antiquity ” . An original suggestion , afaiaa , that the geoglyph is a symbol related to the Trundholm sun horse and associated motifs found on Scandinavian razors and rock art .

Flemming Kaul has been the main instigator in suggesting that the symbol(s) are derived from Indo -European myth and represent the sun on it’s daily journey from east to west , whilst a boat or chariot takes it on the underworld return west to east journey .
In this case the horse is heading just west of south .
There are problems with the Kaul suggestion but it still has adherents since his initial “Ships on Bronzes ” nearly 20 years ago .

Dolmen del barranc d’Espolla

There are 10 dolmens in the hills surrounding Espolla . None are oriented towards any solstice event and 8 are oriented towards a part of the horizon where the sun will never be seen to rise or set . This is one of the eight .