The Modern Antiquarian. Stone Circles, Ancient Sites, Neolithic Monuments, Ancient Monuments, Prehistoric Sites, Megalithic MysteriesThe Modern Antiquarian

Head To Head   The Modern Antiquarian   General Discussion Forum Start a topic | Search
The Modern Antiquarian
Re: Wind farms in Scotland
80 messages
Select a forum:
moss wrote:
Just thought I would add another link for the Stornaway Project on the Isle of Lewis. It has been reduced to 42 wind turbines now, and Druim Dubh stone circle it is said will be protected.
http://www.stornowaywind.com/w[...]way-Wind-Farm-2011-English.pdf

As for the Blackhills, it still seems to be in the stages of negotiation, and what you have is the usual suspects trying to make money on the quick..
In all this, two things become clear, green energy is seen as a way to make profit by some but not all, but we do need different forms of energy. Look at hydro-fracturing and compare its consequences to the environment with the hassle of wind turbines on the horizon and I know which one I want. Again compared to nuclear power stations and the business of getting rid of radio-active material, the visuality and disruption of building turbines is something we perhaps have to live with, though the Stornoway project is to build 31 kilometres of service stone roads.
Wishing for a 'pure' view in Scotland is all good and fine but people want energy to heat and light their homes. The 'nimbyism' found in southern England, really its about how much your house will sell for if it becomes blighted by wind turbines, is perhaps not echoed in the wider reaches of the Scottish landscape, its more to do with aesthetics.....


I do agree with most of the above, although having spoken to a resident of the island, it seems there is also a practical concern that the turbines are shut down if the wind is too strong (rendering them dangerous, I guess) - and that the wind in Lewis is often stronger than the safe operating speed of the turbines. Oh, that and the fact that most of the power would be shipped to the mainland (not exactly "shipped" but you know what I mean) which would mean a lot of the generated power is lost in transit, meaning something a little more local to it's destination might be preferred.

A middle ground is required, perhaps.

G x


Reply | with quote
goffik
Posted by goffik
16th November 2011ce
12:53

In reply to:

Re: Wind farms in Scotland (moss)

Messages in this topic: